Capri dining suffers from a binary reputation: either overpriced tourist traps near the funicular or reservation-only sanctuaries for the yachting crowd. The reality is a thin margin of authentic kitchens that balance local raw materials with the demands of a high-turnover seasonal population. Most visitors mistake the abundance of lemon-trellised courtyards for quality, leading them to pay for ambiance rather than execution. To eat well here, you must distinguish between the historic trattorias that rely on captive foot traffic and the quieter, more focused kitchens that maintain local supply chains despite the logistics of island life.
The geography of the dining scene forces a choice between the high-density zones of the Piazzetta and the more sequestered kitchens tucked into the steep, winding alleys leading toward Marina Piccola or up the slopes toward Anacapri. Street-level spots near the center rarely offer a respite from the crowds, while the kitchens deeper in the residential grids require strict booking lead times. Avoid the main thoroughfares during the lunch rush if you want actual service. Prioritize venues that lean into the specific harvest of the island’s southern cliffs.
Here is where to start.
© Photo Credits: Aurora
01.Aurora
What is it? Aurora sits at Via Fuorlovado, 18, in Capri. It is a fine dining restaurant specializing in Italian, Mediterranean, and seafood preparations.
Why we love it: This is a high-priced destination that leans into the formal luxury of the island. It distinguishes itself from the neighborhood’s more casual trattorias by strictly adhering to a Mediterranean fine-dining code.
Good to Know: Request a table with a sea view when booking Aurora to pair your seafood meal with the coast.
© Photo Credits: Il Riccio Restaurant & Beach Club
02.Il Riccio Restaurant & Beach Club
What is it? Il Riccio Restaurant & Beach Club sits on Via Gradola in Anacapri. This beachfront establishment specializes in Italian and Mediterranean seafood and maintains a fine dining profile.
Why we love it: It occupies a rare stretch of coastline where luxury design meets a rugged sea view. While much of the island demands constant movement, the fine dining focus here encourages a slower pace, making the price range worth the lack of distraction.
Good to Know: Save room for the dessert room at Il Riccio Restaurant & Beach Club, where the Mediterranean influences extend to an extensive display of sweets.
© Photo Credits: Da Paolino
03.Da Paolino
What is it? Da Paolino sits on Via Palazzo a Mare, 11 in Capri. It operates as a luxury restaurant focusing on Italian, Seafood, and Mediterranean cuisines.
Why we love it: This venue distinguishes itself through a rare combination of Mediterranean fine dining and an expansive terrace setting. Its pricing reflects a luxury experience, positioning it as a distinct choice for those prioritizing an open-air atmosphere over the enclosed interiors found elsewhere on the island.
Good to Know: The terrace at Da Paolino offers a rare sea view, so request a table near the perimeter when booking to maximize the outlook.
© Photo Credits: Mare by Casa Tua
04.Mare by Casa Tua
What is it? Mare by Casa Tua sits at Via Mulo, 76. It is a restaurant focusing on Italian, Mediterranean, and seafood preparations.
Why we love it: While many Capri dining spots rely on the passing trade of the main piazzas, this beachfront location offers a distinct shift in scale. It commands a premium price point, but the trade-off is a level of privacy and a sea view that remains rare on this stretch of coast.
Good to Know: Mare by Casa Tua highlights Mediterranean seafood traditions; request a table on the terrace to sit directly over the water.
© Photo Credits: Lido del Faro
05.Lido del Faro
What is it? Lido del Faro is a restaurant located on Str. Faro di Carena in Anacapri. It sits in a beachfront location and offers a menu defined by Italian and Mediterranean seafood.
Why we love it: While many Capri dining rooms lean into formality, the price point here reflects its position as a luxury destination that prioritizes its sea view over the typical island bustle. It is the rare spot that uses its isolation on the edge of the island to curate a focused Mediterranean seafood experience rather than relying on the usual tourist-heavy menus found closer to the ferry docks.
Good to Know: The bar at Lido del Faro is the best place to pair a glass of local white wine with the day’s seafood selection before moving to a table overlooking the water.
© Photo Credits: Casa Tua Restaurant
06.Casa Tua Restaurant
What is it? Casa Tua Restaurant sits at Via Vittorio Emanuele, 39 in Capri. It focuses on Italian, Mediterranean, and seafood cuisine within a fine dining setting.
Why we love it: This venue avoids the casual churn of the surrounding streets by leaning into a deliberate, romantic pace. The kitchen balances Mediterranean seafood traditions with the rigor of fine dining, justifying its place in a higher price tier than the local tourist-focused bistros.
Good to Know: The sea view remains the primary draw at Casa Tua Restaurant, so request a table near the glass when you call to secure your reservation.
© Photo Credits: Le Monzù
07.Le Monzù
What is it? Le Monzù sits on Via Tragara, a ten-minute walk from the Piazzetta di Capri and a short stroll from the shops of Via Camerelle. This fine-dining destination holds a Michelin star and is currently ranked among the best luxury restaurants in Italy by 50 Top Italy.
Why we love it: The kitchen focuses on refined Italian seafood and Mediterranean flavors, distinguishing itself from the casual trattorias found closer to the island’s main square. Its location creates a rare, quiet atmosphere for such a high-rated venue, which commands a higher price point than the bustling spots near the Marina Piccola.
Good to Know: The terrace at Le Monzù provides an immediate vantage point for the surrounding landscape, but guests should adhere to the smart and elegant dress code to match the formal tone of the dining room.
© Photo Credits: Ambasciatori
08.Ambasciatori
What is it? Ambasciatori is a fine dining restaurant located on Via Roma, 36 in Capri. It focuses on the intersection of seafood, Italian, and Mediterranean cuisines.
Why we love it: This venue positions itself in the upper price tier of the local market, favoring a refined atmosphere that leverages its Mediterranean seafood focus. The terrace provides a distinct sea view, separating the experience from the pedestrian foot traffic found elsewhere on Via Roma.
Good to Know: The terrace at Ambasciatori offers a specific vantage point to accompany their seafood-heavy menu; request a table at the edge of the space to maximize the sea view.
© Photo Credits: Fuoco by Casa Tua
09.Fuoco by Casa Tua
What is it? Fuoco by Casa Tua sits at Via Vittorio Emanuele, 39, in Capri. It is a fine dining restaurant that balances Mediterranean and Italian seafood-focused menus with a dedicated bar.
Why we love it: This is a high-priced venue that strips away the island’s typical tourist clamor in favor of a focused, luxury environment. The kitchen prioritizes a Mediterranean approach to seafood, ensuring the quality justifies the significant investment of a dinner here.
Good to Know: The bar at Fuoco by Casa Tua offers a refined selection of spirits that pairs specifically with the restaurant’s Mediterranean seafood menu.
© Photo Credits: Da Luigi ai Faraglioni
10.Da Luigi ai Faraglioni
What is it? Da Luigi ai Faraglioni sits at Via dei Faraglioni, 5. This fine dining restaurant in Capri focuses on a Mediterranean menu of seafood and Italian staples.
Why we love it: The restaurant commands a direct sea view that defines the dining experience, distinguishing it from the enclosed trattorias found elsewhere on the island. It manages a higher price bracket with a romantic atmosphere that relies on its coastal position rather than interior artifice.
Good to Know: The seafood-heavy menu at Da Luigi ai Faraglioni is best paired with a crisp local white wine to match the intensity of the sea air.
